Leg 1: 1400m - Leg 2: 400m - Leg 3: 800m - Leg 4: 1400m
| Lane | Team | Squad | Athlete 1 | Athlete 2 | Athlete 3 | Athlete 4 | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Colgate |
A | Laverde | Caracciolo | Mellin | Manners | NT | |
| 2 | A | Grecco | Mansfield | Berthiaume | Whitnell | NT | ||
| 3 | St. John Fisher |
A | Highers | Shea | Collins | Corey | NT | |
| 4 | unattached | A | Kavanagh | Banafato | Carty | Cook | NT | |
| 5 | Coast Guard |
A | Winters | White | Thorburn | Shales | NT | |
| 6 | Lock Haven |
A | Klinger | Owens | Manley | Kiser | NT | |
| 7 | Mount Holyoke |
A | Jacob | Ravino | Nash | Selkin | DNF | |
| 8 | Hofstra |
A | McDonnell | Dietrich | Orellana | Masciarelli | NT | |
| 9 | Brockport St. |
A | Masker | Metz | Sibley | Daily | NT | |
| 10 | Big Blue Track Club | A | Huh | Fischer | Tran | Whitehurst | NT | |
| 11 | GBTC | A | Long | Foster | Harmon | Hatas | NT | |
| 12 | Oneonta |
A | Basco | Johnson | Gallagher | Luby | NT |